This week's Agent Spotlight features Jim McCarthy of Dystel & Goderich Literary Management.
About: "Jim McCarthy interned for DGLM while studying urban design at New York University. Upon graduating, Jim realized he would much rather continue working with books than make the jump (as he had originally intended) to the field of city planning.
"As an avid fiction reader, his interests encompass both literary and commercial works. He is particularly interested in literary women’s fiction, underrepresented voices, mysteries, romance, paranormal fiction, and anything unusual or unexpected. In addition to fiction he is also interested in narrative nonfiction, humor, memoir, paranormal nonfiction, and anything related to architecture, planning, or real estate.
"Jim was raised just outside of NYC and currently lives in Brooklyn." (Link)
Status: Open to submissions.
What He's Looking For:
Per AgentQuery:
Fiction Genres: Literary Fiction, chick lit, mystery, commercial fiction, fantasy, women's fiction, humor/satire, romance, young adult, multi-cultural.
Non-Fiction Genres: Sports, politics, memoirs, dating/relationships, current affairs, business, narrative, humor, home/design.
From his bio:
"As an avid fiction reader, his interests encompass both literary and commercial works. He is particularly interested in literary women’s fiction, underrepresented voices, mysteries, romance, paranormal fiction, and anything unusual or unexpected. In addition to fiction he is also interested in narrative nonfiction, humor, memoir, paranormal nonfiction, and anything related to architecture, planning, or real estate." (Link)
As of 06/2010:
"I just want to find something different! There isn’t any one thing that I’m desperate to find. It’s more that I’m chasing a feeling: when you hit something that stops you in your tracks and makes you think, 'Now that hasn’t been done that way before.'" (Link)
As of Oct 2009:
"I’d love to find literary horror whether in the adult or young adult realm. There simply aren’t enough great ghost stories crossing my desk, which I think is a shame. I want the book equivalent of Paranormal Activity. If you can scare the bejesus out of me, I’d be delighted to sign you on.
"I don’t know if steampunk is really the next big thing or whether people just expect it to be, but in either case, I think it’s a fascinating genre and would love to see more of it cross my desk. For those who don’t know yet, the definition of steampunk can be found here. And for those local to New York, there’s even a steampunk haunted house coming up which looks like it might be made of awesome. Who knows? Maybe I’ll see you there.
"I’d be more than happy to take a look at alternative histories. Whether it’s fantastical reimaginings of the past a la Diana Gabaldon or stories about ways that history might have played out like Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America. Robert Cowley’s What If? series provides endless food for thought. This site provides lots of examples of the sort of books that have been done in the category before. I think there’s room to bring the genre more into the mainstream, and I’d love to see it happen." (Link)
As of May 2009:
"I want to see stories that aren't being told. I think there are a lot of groups that don't necessarily see themselves represented in the literary market as much as they should: whether that means underrepresented ethnic, religious, or even geographic narratives or simply people who feel like they fall out of the mainstream, I'd love to have a look. " (Link)
What He's Not Looking For:
Picture books, middle grade, dramatic works.
His Advice to Writers:
"If you think you can give up writing, then give it up. If you can't ... if you know that no matter how much stress or rejection or frustration you face, that you can never stop writing? In that case, never give up. Publishing is too hard to face if you aren't in it for the right reasons. But it's not too hard to break into if it's what you need to do." (Link)
Quotables:
"I want my authors to be as blunt as humanly possible. There's nothing worse to me than suddenly springing something on me, whether it's, "But my dream was to be published by someone else," or "I really thought I would get more money," or "I always expected that you'd be in touch more often during the submission process." Agents, by and large, have very thick skins. We can handle most anything an author can throw at us. But if things are held back, or feelings spared, there's no way we can go back in time to undo and redo anything." (Link with more)
"...I certainly do love my vampire romances. And zombies, succubi, werewolves, and all of those other glorious fantastical creatures. But what I'm seeing a lot of (and am really encouraged by) is that the boundaries of the subgenre are being stretched. I love fiction that is fantastical--alternate worlds, alternative realities, that sort of thing. It isn't so much about the entities you're writing about as it is the ability to create a world that feels wholly realized and entirely believable in its own right." (Link)
The Agency:
"Being involved in every stage of putting together a non-fiction book proposal, offering substantial editing on fiction manuscripts, and coming up with book ideas for authors looking for their next project is as much a part of our work as selling, negotiating contracts, and collecting monies for our clients. We follow a book from its inception through its sale to a publisher, its publication, and beyond. Our commitment to our writers does not, by any means, end when we have collected our commission. This is one of the many things that makes us unique in a very competitive business." (Link)
Pet-Peeves:
"Oh lord. If there's one thing I can't stand, it's the movie pitch. Primarily because it's usually done so poorly. 'If Dan Brown read MADAME BOVARY while shrooming, and 2001: A Space Odyssey was playing in the background...' " (Link)
Editorial Agent?
Yes, as needed. Mr. McCarthy talks about his various agenting roles (including being editorial) a little in this interview. And, Jane Dystel praises his editorial mind in this post.
Web Presence:
D&GLM Website
D&GLM Blog
WeBook
AAR
LinkedIn.
QueryTracker, AgentQuery, & AuthorAdvance.
Clients:
A list of Dystel & Goderich clients is available on the website.
Mr. McCarthy's clients include: Cyn Balog, Mary Carter, Cynthia Ceilan, Mark Henry, Geoff Herbach, Phoebe Kitanidis, Victoria Laurie, Richelle Mead, Michelle Rowen, Carrie Ryan, Barb Schwarz, David Sears, Margaret C. Sullivan, Julia Templeton, Suzanne Young, among others.
*Clients with young adult works are in bold.
Sales:
As of 07/2010, Mr. McCarthy is listed on Publisher's Marketplace as having made 6 deals in the last 12 months, 43 overall, and 1 six-figure+ deal. Recent sales include 4 young adult, 1 paranormal, and 1 historical non-fiction.
Note: PM is usually not a complete representation of sales.
Query Methods:
E-mail: Yes (preferred).
Snail-Mail: Yes.
Online-Form: No.
Submission Guidelines (always verify):
Send an e-query, synopsis, and sample chapter. (Link)
Per the D&GLM website:
"Enclose a cover letter, outline or brief synopsis of the work (with word count if possible), a sample chapter, and a stamped, self-addressed envelope for our response. Please type all of your correspondence and double space everything other than the cover letter. E-mail queries are fine, but keep them brief and make sure your cover letter is in the body of the e-mail. We won't open attachments if they come with a blank e-mail. Please be sure to query only one agent at this agency. We will not review queries sent to more than one of us."
See the agency website for complete, up-to-date submission guidelines.
Response Times:
The agency's stated response time for queries is six to eight weeks. If you do not hear back in that time, feel free to resend. Jim McCarthy seems to have very quick response times ranging from hours to a couple weeks on queries and just a few weeks (or even sooner!) to a month on requested material.
What's the Buzz?
Mr. McCarthy is top notch. He has fabulous clients and sales, a great work ethic, fast response times, a terrific sense of humor, and his clients really seem to love him. I've heard nothing but good about him and the D&GLM agency.
Worth Your Time:
Interviews:
Interview with Agent Extraordinaire, Jim McCarthy at adventures in space (06/2010).
Agent Advice interview with Jim McCarthy on the Guide to Literary Agents blog (2009).
Interview with Jim McCarthy at The League of Reluctant Adults (2007).
Stuff on the agency site:
Jim McCarthy's personal note on the Dystel & Goderich site.
The agency's newsletter is also available on the website, which may be of interest.
Blog posts:
"Why I Am An Agent (Jim)" - Jim McCarthy shares how he became an agent.
"Jim McCarthy's Reading Process" - Just what it sounds like. Great blog post from 2007.
Because there are just too many great posts to link, I'm linking the "Jim" label on the agency blog, which will take you to many, though not all, of Jim McCarthy's past posts (and posts he's been mentioned in).
Other:
You can read Agent Appreciation Day posts for Jim McCarthy here, here, here, and here.
Contact:
Please see the Dystel & Goderich Literary Management website for contact and query information.
***
Have any experience with this agent? See something that needs updating? Please leave a comment or e-mail me at agentspotlight(at)gmail.com
Note: These agent profiles presently focus on agents who accept children's fiction. They are not interviews. Please take the time to verify anything you might use here before querying an agent. The information found herein is subject to change.