Upcoming Agent Spotlight Interviews & Guest Posts

  • Agent Cortney Radocaj/Author Claire Winn Guest Post + Query Critique & Book Giveaway on 12/1/2021
  • Gemma Cooper Agent Spotlight Interview and Query Critique Giveaway on 12/13/2021
  • Stacey Kondla Agent Spotlight Interview and Query Critique Giveaway on 12/15/2021

Agent Spotlight & Agent Spotlight Updates

  • All Agent Spotlights & Interviews have been updated as of 7/15/2020, and many have been reviewed by the agents. Look for them to be fully updated in 2023.

So Tell Me: Your Ideal Literary Agent

No matter how much research you do, it's nearly impossible to know whether or not you and a prospective agent will be a good match until you've worked together.  But what ARE you looking for in an agent?  Have you thought about it?

Logically, I think it's smart to know what you're looking for before you start looking.  But I also think life and this business require us to be flexible.  After all, we often don't know what we really want until we've experienced it or what we're looking for until we've found it (or hey, until we've experienced the opposite!). 

As it is, however, our view is limited to the present and to what we suspect we'll want.  But that shouldn't stop you from thinking about it and educating yourself on the what you can and can't expect.  So tell me: What are you looking for in an ideal agent?

And if you have an agent (ideal or otherwise), and especially if you've had more than one, I'd love to hear your thoughts as well! 


  1. Great question, Casey.
    1. Connected
    2. Editorial
    3. Good negotiator
    4. Relentless advocate
    5. Able to manage my career
    6. Able to see beyond my current skills into areas I might not be aware of (Eww, a preposition at the end)
    7. Funny and warm are always good :)
    How about you, ma'am?

  2. Great list, Jody!

    I too want a career agent that is knowledgeable, editorial, passionate about my writing, and well connected and respected. Preferably a fantastic negotiator with great sales/clients who will look out for us as a team.

    I'd also like an agent who communicates primarily via e-mail (I'm awkward on the phone), touches bases with me regularly and keeps me updated, and is warm and encouraging.

    Of course, some of that is less important than the rest. But we're talking ideal here! ;]

  3. Jody Jensen ShafferJuly 24, 2009 at 2:30 PM

    Ooh, I love the "touches bases with me regularly and keeps me updated." That's number 8, not necessarily in order. :)

  4. I'll take a one armed Splankton from Mars, but that's me.

  5. I knew my agent was right for me - because she got me excited about my book. she seems to love it more than I do. She also had a very specific plan and idea of my writing career. That was important. we just clicked.

  6. Oh, I like Shelli's answer.

    I want an agent who can see what I really meant, and help me get there. I don't mean I want my agent to be my critique partner, but I do want an agent who won't let me get away with lazy writing, or who can help steer me towards something better. Basically--I want one that won't just submit to editors for me, but who really thinks that writing is key.

  7. Hey Casey! Great topic and thanks for asking!

    #1 First and foremost, my agent should FALL IN LOVE with my work and understand and connect with my long term career goal.

    #2 Encourage and inspire perfection (i.e.: the absolute best the project can be)

    #3 Know the industry and have great connections

    #4 Be detailed and able to communicate well

    #5 MUST have a great personality. For me, this means he/she loves a good laugh, is easy to talk to, is a great listener and drinks coffee.... OK... maybe I could settle for drinks tea or cocoa.

    OH... #6 - MUST LOVE KIDS


  8. You're hilarious, Aimee. Tell me you at least want one that knows what they're doing and has the connections! Otherwise it would be kind of pointless to have one.

    That's awesome Shelli! It would be amazing to have an agent that amped about my writing.

    I love yours too, Beth. Definitely want an agent that pushes me to do my best!

  9. Those are great, Jenni!!! I love the coffee one.

    I also think it's important that the ideal agent is not just connected and knowledgeable, but connected and knowledgeable in the genre(s) we plan to write in. Someone specialized or with a heavy hand in kidlit would be amazing!

  10. Great discussion and very timely for me since I got an agent yesterday.

    I really believe that my current manuscript would sell with or without an agent.

    But I definitely need an agent to help me with my broader career goals. To look at my whole body of work and help me determine which manuscripts are worth pursuing and which aren't. To steer me in the right overall direction.

  11. Yay Corey! See what happens when I ignore my google reader for a day?!? I miss the news right when it debuts (ha!). On second thought, maybe I should ignore it more often.

    Congrats, congrats! I hope your agent-author relationship works out splendidly this time.

  12. Very well said, Corey! And CONGRATULATIONS on getting your new agent! How exciting!!!

  13. As want one agent to grow old with me (sort of like a business marriage), I want someone who
    1) loves my writing,
    2) is great at their job, and
    3) is a funny and decent human being.
    For me, that last part is just as important as the other two. It has to be a good fit for me to stay "married" forever.:)

  14. Well said, Kristi. I think many of us wish for the same, which is why it's so frustrating that we have, often, such limited information on agents.

    Also, one of many reasons we should take advantage of interviewing and questioning before we accept an offer!

  15. Fantastic topic. I'm with Aimee--going for that one-armed Splankton. As long as she doesn't charge weird fees.

    I've actually had a couple of agents who worked hard but weren't any more on top of the trends than I was. Sometimes it just doesn't work out.

    Congratulations, Corey! Wahoo!

    I've just posted a blogpost on researching the right agent and gave this blog a plug. Stop on by! http://annerallen.blogspot.com

  16. Thanks so much, Anne. Really great post. And yay spreading info on agent research!

  17. Ok, if I'm being honest, I want an agent who can tackle the industry like a lion and take care of my artistic sensibilities like a lamb. I have a lot of leeway with the rest.

  18. See, there you go. That's a great sum up!

  19. I want an agent who loves my work and can get other people excited about it too.

    I want someone who can negotiate a fabulous contract for me and who will stick with me for my entire career. Because all this research and letter writing is a royal pain and I really want someone to handle that business end so I can focus on writing novels.

  20. So true Sherrie. I'm so glad there are agents out there to do the contracts and negotiations and be the middle man for us!

  21. Casey, thanks for researching and profiling agents under the agent spotlight. It's a big help for those of us looking for an agent. I'm looking for one to represent and sell my middle grade novel, The Kringle Chronicles, Book One: Catching Santa. You can check out my website and blog at www.marcfranco.com Any way, as for your question ... the ideal agent would be a successful salesperson.

    Marc Franco

  22. Hey Marc! Thanks for stopping by and commenting. Your mg sounds like a lot of fun. Heading over to check out your site now.

    Good luck on the agent hunt!